ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Meg Shaffer is an American author celebrated for her imaginative and heartfelt storytelling. She holds an MFA in TV and Screenwriting from Stephens College.
Her debut novel, The Wishing Game, became a #1 bestseller at Barnes & Noble and a finalist for the Goodreads Choice Awards. The book has been translated into 21 languages, solidifying her place as a rising star in the literary world.
Her second novel, The Lost Story (2024), was featured on the New York Post’s best new books list. Inspired by classic fantasy authors like C.S. Lewis, Shaffer’s works offer a nostalgic yet modern take on magical storytelling for adult readers.
SYNOPSIS (MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS)
Lucy Hart, a devoted teacher’s aide, longs to adopt Christopher, a bright seven-year-old orphan in foster care. However, financial struggles make her dream seem impossible.
When the reclusive author Jack Masterson, creator of the beloved Clock Island series, announces an exclusive competition, Lucy gets a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. The winner will receive Jack’s final manuscript, a prize that could change Lucy’s life forever.
Jack, who stopped writing after a personal tragedy, hosts the contest on the real-life Clock Island, a place filled with wonder, mystery, and healing. Alongside three other contestants, Lucy must navigate challenges inspired by Jack’s books.
With Hugo Reese, Jack’s loyal illustrator, quietly supporting her, Lucy’s love for Christopher becomes her greatest strength. But as the competition unfolds, unexpected twists reveal that the true prize isn’t just a book—it’s the power of believing in one’s dreams.
WHAT WE LIKED ABOUT THE WISHING GAME
One of the book’s greatest strengths is its rare blend of optimism, faith, and kindness. Many adult novels focus on darkness and conflict, but The Wishing Game offers something different—a world where goodness prevails.
The novel beautifully explores themes of redemption, fresh starts, and the idea that families come in all shapes and sizes. In today’s world, where traditional family structures are evolving, this message feels incredibly relevant and heartwarming.
Clock Island is one of the most enchanting fictional settings in recent literature. The island’s whimsical charm, inspired by classic children’s stories, immerses readers in a world that feels both magical and real. It’s a place readers will wish they could visit!
Lucy, Jack, Hugo, and Christopher each bring warmth and depth to the narrative. Their conversations are natural, witty, and emotionally compelling. Watching them grow individually and as a family is truly rewarding.
The competition itself is filled with puzzles and literary Easter eggs, making it feel like a cross between a mystery novel and a fairy tale. Fans of books like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and The Night Circus will find this aspect especially delightful.
WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER ABOUT THE WISHING GAME
While Lucy is well-developed, the other contestants could have been given richer backstories. Understanding their struggles and motivations more deeply would have added extra emotional weight to the competition.
The contest, while fun, could have had greater tension and complexity. Raising the stakes would have made the outcome feel even more meaningful.
Jack Masterson’s decision to stop writing is central to the story’s theme of healing and second chances. A deeper dive into his past would have strengthened the emotional impact of his journey.
Lucy’s sister, Angie, and other side characters could have added more depth to the narrative. Similarly, Clock Island itself, while magical, could have played a bigger role in shaping the characters’ arcs.
The novel introduces a secondary narrative that could have been either developed more thoroughly or removed entirely. Its rushed resolution leaves readers wanting more.
QUOTES
“Another thing I learned in therapy?” Angie said. “The kids in dysfunctional families who act out and rebel are the ones who are the healthiest mentally. They’re the ones who see that something’s wrong. That’s why they act out, because they see the house is burning down, and they’re screaming for help. That was you.”
Don’t give up, Lucy. Always remember that the only wishes ever granted are the wishes of brave children who keep on wishing even when it seems no one is listening because someone always is. Someone like me. Keep wishing. I’m listening.
Hugo, always be quiet when a heart is breaking.
CONCLUSION
The Wishing Game is like a refreshing burst of optimism, reminding us that dreams do come true when we have the courage to chase them.
It’s a heartfelt story of second chances, love, and the magic of believing—perfect for readers looking for an uplifting, enchanting escape. If you’re a fan of books that combine nostalgia, hope, and a touch of whimsy, this one deserves a spot on your reading list!
A reverential admirer of words, Madhu loves watching them weave their bewitching magic on cozy afternoons.